Schools › Elite Minds Montessori
Brooklyn · Columbia Waterfront District

Elite Minds Montessori

A small, women-owned school on Columbia Street serving infants through pre-K, with unusually full staff disclosure — and one accreditation claim that doesn't hold up.

Accreditation check
Elite Minds’ own site says: “We are 1 of 3 verified AMS schools across all of NYC’s 5 boroughs.The count is right; the membership is not. There are exactly three AMS-verified schools in the five boroughs — Battery Park, Children’s Harbor and Paché. Elite Minds returns no result at all in the AMS register (checked August 10, 2026 by name, ZIP and city sweeps). Its own “3 verified AMS schools” link points to an AMS page that now returns 404, which is consistent with a membership that has lapsed. Status: lapsed or inaccurate as currently stated. Two other listings describe the school variously as an AMS “member” and as “fully accredited” by AMS — three different formulations, none currently supported.
See all checks & verify it yourself →

✅ Green  Names its teaching staff, with credentials

Elite Minds publishes a full staff roster with bios — every guide and assistant named, with training and degrees. That is better disclosure than most schools in this directory. Read the credentials as well as the names, though: by our count only about three of the staff hold or are completing a formal Montessori credential. Our rating measures disclosure, not depth.

At a glance

Snapshot

Address295 Columbia Street, Brooklyn, NY 11231 — confirmed by the school’s own site and by two current DOHMH permits (infant/toddler and preschool), checked 11 Aug 2026. Note: the NYC Facilities Database lists this school at 117 Union Street; that record is out of date.
Ages3 months – 5 years (listings elsewhere say 12mo–6 or 6mo–4; the school’s own site says 3 months)
LicensingTwo current DOHMH permits — infants/toddlers (ages 0–2, capacity 33) and preschool (ages 2–5, capacity 16). Both “passed inspection with no violations”, 26 June 2026
TuitionPublished on the school’s site, but as images rather than text — see below
OwnershipFor-profit · Elite Minds, Inc. · self-described women-owned
AffiliationMember, Brooklyn Coalition of Early Childhood Programs (verified). AMS claim — see the accreditation check above
TransparencyGREEN — full staff roster with credentials
The neighborhood

Columbia Waterfront District

Stylized illustration of brownstone Brooklyn: rows of stoops and street trees on a quiet residential block

A narrow strip between Cobble Hill and the harbour, cut off from the brownstone belt by the BQE. Quiet, low-rise and walkable, with Mother Cabrini Park a block away. Different sources place the school in Red Hook, Carroll Gardens or Columbia Waterfront — it is genuinely on the seam.

🌊 Harbour edge🌳 Mother Cabrini Park🚇 F/G at Carroll St🛣️ BQE divide

Programs

One small campus running four classrooms — Buttercups (12–18 months), Daisies, Lillies and Daffodils — with a two-to-three-hour uninterrupted work cycle. Alongside the Montessori materials the school runs music, a weekly artist study, yoga, gardening and farm-to-table cooking, and a daily mindfulness practice. Outdoor time is at Mother Cabrini Park.

Languages are described inconsistently: the site’s own copy lists English, Spanish and Mandarin, while its page description says “bilingual Spanish immersion”. Worth asking on a tour which languages are actually spoken in your child’s room, and by whom.

A summer camp runs 7 July – 12 August, $750 (to 2:30pm) or $825 (to 5pm), two-week minimum.

Tuition

The school does publish its 2026–27 rates — but as screenshot images, so the figures are not selectable, searchable or readable by a screen reader. We don’t reproduce numbers we can’t reliably read, so ask for them in writing.

The structure is clear enough: a 10-month year (September–June) by default, with an opt-in 12-month option for infants aged 3–23 months; monthly instalments; discounts for siblings and for annual or half-yearly payment; payment by brightwheel or cheque. Early drop-off from 8am is $30. For scale, the New York Post reported in April 2026 that infant tuition here “can top $32,000” a year — a press figure, not one we have confirmed against the school’s own schedule.

Leadership & staff

Founder and Executive Director Laurie Torres holds a BBA from Pace, completed Montessori leadership training at Montessori Teachers College in April 2025, and is pursuing an M.S.Ed. at Brooklyn College. Named alongside her: a Director of Operations, two Education Directors — one a New York State certified teacher, one an infant/toddler guide — a guide trained through the West Side Montessori teacher education programme, a Montessori accelerated assistant, and a further guide in training at West Side Montessori, plus around ten more staff with bios.

That is a genuinely full roster, and it is why this school rates GREEN. The honest caveat: only about three of those people hold or are completing a formal Montessori credential. For a school of this size that is not unusual, but it is worth weighing against the “trained teachers in every classroom” language in its AMS claim.

What parents say

There is almost nothing to go on, and we would rather say that than pad it. Across Google, Yelp, Winnie, Nextdoor and Mommy Poppins the school has listings but zero reviews. It is not indexed on Niche, GreatSchools, PrivateSchoolReview or Care.com at all.

The only genuine parent commentary anywhere is five entries on Park Slope Parents, all positive, and all dated between January 2020 and November 2023 — the newest is nearly three years old, so we treat all of it as historical. Parents described a warm, small, community-centred school, praised the dual-language teaching, and singled out tuition as more reasonable than other Montessori options nearby. One noted the school is an easy walk despite sitting the far side of the BQE. A 2022 camp review described children spending most of the day outdoors and coming home “happy and filthy — just as summer camp should be.”

Two cautions on that sample. Five reviews on one platform is far too thin to characterise a school, and Park Slope Parents states that it moderates and may decline to publish reviews — positive or negative. So the absence of criticism there is not evidence that none exists. We found no critical or mixed review anywhere, and no reviews at all from 2024 onward.

Ignore the three recommendations on Alignable: that is a business-networking site and the recommenders are a consulting firm and an accountant, not families.

Heard around town

Community chatter, gathered from public sources. Paraphrased closely, with parents unnamed. Dates given so you can judge how current it is.

The community garden dispute — the one story that generated real coverage. In April 2026 the New York Post reported that the school had lost access to the Urban Meadow, a GreenThumb-licensed community garden it had used for around seven years, after the locks were changed without warning in about July 2025. The school’s director said the schools involved had been treated like “second-class citizens.” A garden board member cited a liability determination and children trampling crop beds, and later floated a donation in exchange for access parameters; the city’s Parks Department said it had contacted the garden group, because tying donations to access is not permitted.

NY Post, 12 April 2026

The other side of it. Hell Gate covered the same dispute in May 2026 and framed it as a fight in which nobody wins: the garden coordinators said they had closed general access in order to comply better with city policy, on top of everything else involved in stewarding a small piece of public green space. Worth reading both if this matters to you — it is a genuine neighbour disagreement, not a scandal. A third local outlet, the Court Street Journal, also picked it up.

Hell Gate, 1 May 2026 · Court Street Journal, 17 April 2026

One parent post, August 2025. A family advertising their toddler’s place on Reddit said the education had been excellent, particularly for two-year-olds, and that they were leaving only because their child had won a free 3-K seat. Notable operationally: they mentioned they could not exit their contract unless they found a replacement family. Worth asking about withdrawal terms.

r/nycparents, 22 August 2025

Otherwise: nothing. No discussion of this school on r/Brooklyn, r/carrollgardens, r/AskNYC, r/nyc, r/Montessori or six other borough subreddits; nothing in the Brooklyn Paper, Brooklyn Eagle or Red Hook Star-Revue; no independent parent-blog coverage. For a school of this size that is normal, not a red flag — but it does mean the garden story is doing a lot of the work above.

Swept 10 August 2026

Stale marketing to be aware of. Two third-party listings still advertise “frequent visits to Urban Meadow Garden.” Per the coverage above, that access has been closed since roughly July 2025.

Checked 10 August 2026

Admissions

Rolling admissions. As of August 2026 the school advertised places for 2025–26, summer camp 2026 and the 2026–27 school year. Ask specifically about: the languages actually spoken in your child’s classroom; which staff hold Montessori credentials; the withdrawal and contract terms; and the school’s current AMS status, given the check above.

Sources: the school’s own website (programmes, staff, tuition structure, AMS claim), checked August 10, 2026; NYC DOHMH Child Care Connect live permit lookup — permits 106173 (infants/toddlers, expires 13 Dec 2027) and 106182 (preschool, expires 4 Jan 2028), both recorded as passing inspection 26 June 2026; NYC Facilities Database (DCP, `ji82-xba5`, data updated 16 July 2026); American Montessori Society register queried via its Algolia index by name, ZIP and city sweep, with permalink status confirmed in-browser against a known-good control; Brooklyn Coalition of Early Childhood Programs member list; Park Slope Parents preschool directory (five parent reviews, 2020–2023); New York Post, 12 April 2026; Hell Gate, 1 May 2026; Court Street Journal, 17 April 2026; r/nycparents, 22 August 2025. Independent profile, not affiliated with the school.

Health & safety record

Violations heard and decided at the city’s administrative tribunal. We publish these in full, including when there are none.

  • 7cases on record
  • 2019–2026period covered
  • 6sustained
  • 1dismissed
  • $2,700penalties imposed

For comparison: across all 18,161 DOHMH child-care cases heard at OATH, 63.1% were sustained, 21.3% ended in default and 13.1% were dismissed. Most citations concern records, repairs and paperwork — staff immunisation files, premises upkeep, sink water temperature, background-check timing — rather than incidents involving a child.

Source: NYC Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings, case status data, checked 11 August 2026. These are adjudicated outcomes, not inspection allegations. The record gives the rule cited and the result, but never the inspector’s narrative — the charge text always reads “see attached NOV”. Outcomes can change on appeal. Something wrong? Tell us.

From the city’s live child-care register

  • Latest inspection: 6/26/26 — Initial Annual Inspection: passed with no violations
  • Drinking-water lead test: done — not elevated
  • Permit held by: ELITE MINDS, INC. — infant/toddler permit 106173 expires 12/13/27 (cap 33)
Prior inspections (since August 2024):
  • 4/9/26 — Initial Annual Inspection - Passed inspection with no violations
  • 2/25/26 — Monitoring Inspection Non-Routine - Reinspection Required; Violations corrected at time of inspection
  • 1/21/26 — Monitoring Inspection Non-Routine - Reinspection Required; Fines pending
  • 10/9/25 — Initial Annual Inspection - Passed inspection with no violations
  • 7/30/25 — Compliance Inspection of Open Violations - Reinspection Required; Violations corrected at time of inspection
  • 7/23/25 — Compliance Inspection of Open Violations - Reinspection Required; Fines pending
  • 5/30/25 — Initial Annual Inspection - Reinspection Required; Fines pending
  • 12/13/24 — Initial Annual Inspection - Reinspection Required; Fines pending

Source: NYC Health Department Child Care Connect (live register), checked 22 August 2026; refreshed weekly. Inspection lines are the Department’s own summary results. Pre-adjudicated citation details are not republished here; adjudicated outcomes appear above. Lead results shown with the Department’s protocol status.

Community

Join the discussion

Current or former family? This school has almost no public reviews — first-hand experience is genuinely useful here.