Schools › Choice Charter School
Bronx · Mott Haven

Choice Charter School

NYC's first public Montessori — free and lottery-based, PreK through 5th grade, in the South Bronx (formerly "NYC Montessori Charter School").

Amber  Staff transparency

As a public school its principals are named through the NYC DOE, but the school's own public-facing staff and credential listings are thin. Why this matters →

At a glance

Snapshot

Location423 East 138th Street, Bronx, NY 10454 · Mott Haven · map ↗
AgesPreK – Grade 5
CostFree — public charter; enroll by public lottery (no tuition)
LeadershipPrincipals Abeku Hayes & Alyssa Norris (per NYC DOE)
Registered nameAuthorised by the NYS Board of Regents as Choice Charter School, formerly New York City Montessori Charter School (DBN 84X554); the rename takes effect with the charter term beginning 2022–23. Some city records still carry the former name.
TypeNYC public charter · Montessori model (two co-teachers per class)
Also known asformerly New York City Montessori Charter School
Contactchoicecs.org ↗ · DBN 84X554
Cost
Free
public charter
Enrolled
~190
Classroom
2 / room
co-teachers
Photos

See the school

Choice Charter School building
Exterior
Inside Choice Charter School
Interior
Location — interactive map. Open in Google Maps ↗
The neighborhood

Mott Haven

Stylized illustration of Mott Haven: brick buildings, a water tower and an elevated subway line

Mott Haven — the South Bronx's fast-changing "SoBro" arts district — mixes historic brownstone rows and brick apartment blocks under the elevated 6 train, with a growing family population and new waterfront parks along the Harlem River.

🎨 SoBro arts district🧱 Brownstones + brick🚆 Elevated 6 train🎟️ Free schools

Overview

Choice Charter School bills itself as NYC's first public Montessori school. It's a free, tuition-less public charter in Mott Haven serving roughly 180–200 children from PreK through 5th grade, running Montessori classrooms with two co-teachers each. (It was renamed from "New York City Montessori Charter School.")

Programs & ages

PreK through Grade 5 in mixed-age Montessori classrooms — a rare chance to continue Montessori into the elementary years at no cost.

Cost & access

It's free — a public charter, so there's no tuition. Admission is by public lottery rather than private application, and it's open to all NYC students. This makes it one of the few genuinely free routes into Montessori through elementary; see our free 3-K & Pre-K guide for the broader free/public picture.

Leadership

As a public charter, its principals (Abeku Hayes and Alyssa Norris) are listed through the NYC DOE. Beyond leadership, the school's public site is light on named staff and credentials — hence the Amber transparency rating.

Authenticity

It follows the Montessori model but is not stated to be AMS- or AMI-accredited, and — like all publicly-funded programs — must fold in city/state curriculum requirements. Treat it as a Montessori-method public school; see the authenticity guide.

What parents say

Independent review volume is limited for this school. We'd rather show nothing than inflate it — check InsideSchools and the DOE's school-survey data for the most current parent/teacher sentiment.

Heard around town

Signals from public parent forums and listservs and our own parent & alumni interviews. Forum chatter is opinion — take it with a grain of salt; interview quotes are first-hand and shared with permission.

We haven't surfaced candid community chatter about Choice Charter yet. Heard something in a Bronx parent group? We'd love to add it.

Admissions

Apply through the public-charter lottery (free). Charter admissions run on their own timeline, separate from the private-school ISAAGNY calendar and the DOE 3-K/Pre-K MySchools process — check the school's site for the current application window.

Sources: choicecs.org; NYC Public Schools (schools.nyc.gov/schools/X554); InsideSchools. Verified July 2026. Independent profile, not affiliated with the school.

Health & safety record

Violations heard and decided at the city’s administrative tribunal. We publish these in full, including when there are none.

  • 12cases on record
  • 2019–2024period covered
  • 12default — not contested
  • $22,200penalties imposed

This is the largest enforcement record in our directory. Every one of the twelve is a default — no one appeared to contest them, which is not the same as a charge being proven. Nine were issued under the school’s former name, New York City Montessori Charter School; NYSED confirms the rename (DBN 84X554). Cited under Article 43 (school-based child care), not Article 47.

For comparison: across all 18,161 DOHMH child-care cases heard at OATH, 63.1% were sustained, 21.3% ended in default and 13.1% were dismissed. Most citations concern records, repairs and paperwork — staff immunisation files, premises upkeep, sink water temperature, background-check timing — rather than incidents involving a child.

Source: NYC Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings, case status data, checked 11 August 2026. These are adjudicated outcomes, not inspection allegations. The record gives the rule cited and the result, but never the inspector’s narrative — the charge text always reads “see attached NOV”. Outcomes can change on appeal. Something wrong? Tell us.

Community

Join the discussion